by KatieMo21 on Thu Apr 02, 2009 8:31 am
I've read alot of studies on what makes you male or female (yah, I know, it's weird, I have alot of gay friends though so maybe thats why??) There was a theory in the 70's that stated that it was environmental and social factors that made you inherently male or female....but I watched the TLC interview (they have the best odd, random stories) with the "test" subject....40 years later.....and yah, nature defenitely overrode nuture. See, the subject that they did this on was born male.....he had a botched circumcision.....his parents wanted to cover it up to the world...I mean, how could you be a man without a penis? (note the sarcasm) So, they put him under the care of a prominent psychotherapist who was trying to prove that "sex" is determined by environmental factors and can in fact be programmed by various experiences and stimulus in ones life.....but, as it turned out, though he had a girls name, dressed and looked like a girl.....was treated in every way like a female....he always knew he didn't feel like one. He wanted to wear pants and play with trucks....his parents would take them away. Around puberty he became suicidal becuase he was attracted to women. After a psychiatric commitment, his parents took him to the psychologist and told him the truth. The psychologist had him meet someone transgendered who was pretty, femine, the perfect woman, and who was happy. This, in fact, backfired....and he became more adamant that he was a man....and the transvestite told him that he should follow his heart....his parents supported him, changed his name back, let him become a man agian, etc. He got married and everything.....the documentary ended with his suicide.... he was so tramatized by what had been done......I dunno.....I feel that if people are gay, they're born that way. If your a man, youre born a man, if you're a woman, you're born a woman....and as far as transgendered people.....I dunno what to think. I believe enviornment does play a small role as to how masculine or feminine you are, but in the end you are what you are i guess........